Ajami’s Syria Rebellion; Homs Bombed

Fouad Ajami’s new book, The Syrian Rebellion, is reviewed by Dexter Filkins in the New York Times. I have a copy of the book that Prof. Ajami kindly sent to me and have gone through it. It is classic Ajami, an excellent read filled with wonderful details. Ajami knows the region with all its prejudices and over the top characters better than just about anyone. His sense of history and choice of words is unsurpassed. One of the first books I read on the Middle East was The Arab Predicament: Arab Political Thought and Practice since 1967 . What a brilliant book. It has shaped the way I understand the ideologies of the Arabs and it introduced me to many of the region’s greatest thinkers, dreamers, and con-men. I am also a great admirer of his, The Vanished Imam: Musa al Sadr and the Shia of Lebanon, Ajami exasperated many with his full on support of the Iraq invasion. He is also a supporter of US and Western intervention in Syria following the Libyan and Yugoslav model, which I have argued against. Anyone who wants to understand the Syrian Rebellion must read Fouad Ajami.

“Coming Apart” By Dexter Filkins
Review of
240 pp. Hoover Institution Press. $19.95.

Fourteen months ago, as ordinary Syrians were just beginning to gather in large numbers to call for their leaders to quit power, a cherub-faced 13-year-old named Hamza Ali al-Khateeb was taken into custody after he’d been caught scrawling an antigovernment slogan on a wall at a protest in the town of Jiza. A month later, when Hamza’s body was returned to his parents, it bore signs of the most hideous torture. His face had been beaten purple, his jaw and kneecaps pulverized, his body stabbed and torched. His penis had been chopped off.

There was a time, and not so long ago, when a Syrian dictator could plausibly assume that such a demonstration of official sadism would silence any popular murmurings for a more democratic form of governance. Brutality always worked before. But by April 2011, the Middle East had changed — Syrians had changed, even if the regime of Bashar al-Assad had not. The mutilation of young Hamza did not crush the Syrians; it enraged and catalyzed them. The result, little more than a year later, is an epic struggle that horrifies and inspires. It’s hard to imagine that the dictator and his confederates can hang on, but still they do.

In “The Syrian Rebellion,” the Middle East scholar Fouad Ajami weaves the threads of Syria’s past with the events of the previous year to give us a portrait of the country as it hurtles toward its moment of decisive transformation. This is no small feat: Syria is a country of enormous ethnic and religious complexity, and the story is moving very fast. “The Syrian Rebellion” is an elegant and edifying book, written on the fly, by an observer who retains an almost loving intimacy with his subject. But it is underlain by a sobering subtext: Ajami suggests that the dynamics of Syria’s politics and history are leading inexorably toward a catastrophe, or at least no quick and happy end. If he’s right, we have probably not yet seen the worst.

Syria is another of the improbable constructions that arose from the ruins of the Ottoman Empire after World War I. The new country was a grab bag of ethnicities and religions, conjured up by colonial mapmakers with little regard for either. In Syria, the dominant group is not the Sunni Arabs, who make up the overwhelming majority; nor even the Christians, a significant minority; but the Alawites, a heterodox Shiite sect that constitutes 12 percent of the population. A largely rural people at the time of Syria’s birth, the Alawites came to dominate first the military and then the country itself. Their ascent was aided by the French, who ruled until the 1940s, and who, in the way of the colonial master, maintained a policy of favoring minorities at the expense of the Sunnis. Hafez al-Assad, a steely-eyed air force officer, secured his hold on power in the 1970s, using the secular-minded Baath Party as his vehicle (its sister party, eventually led by Saddam Hussein, lay across the border in Iraq). When Hafez died, in 2000, he bequeathed power to his son, the London-educated Bashar, age 34.

The old man, as Ajami shows, pursued his designs with a brutal logic, setting up a ruling class of Alawites, some Christians and a select number of Sunni businessmen, stifling dissent, stifling the Sunni majority’s yearnings for a freer expression of their faith, offering instead the slogans of Pan-Arabism and permanent war with the Jews. “Let them eat anti-Zionism,” is how Ajami describes it. There was little flexibility in the regime, little color, no air. The defining moment came in 1982, when an uprising broke out in the predominantly Sunni city of Hama, led by the Muslim Brotherhood. Assad crushed the revolt with savage finality, leveling entire blocks and killing as many as 30,000 of his countrymen. For 29 years, Hama stayed quiet.

Then, in 2000, came Bashar, the heir with the British-Sunni wife, the not-quite-favored son (the chosen, Basel, died in a car accident), the ophthalmologist with no chin. Ajami makes it clear that Bashar was not his father’s equal — neither in competence nor in temperament — and that an already despotic regime transformed into a decadent enterprise without the self-discipline that had once checked its worst abuses. “Pity the Syrians,” Ajami writes. “They had been raised on the legend that their country was the ‘beating heart of Arabism.’ They woke up amidst the debris, and this squalid kleptocracy was what they had gotten in the bargain.” I can personally attest to the decadence: In the summer of 2003, I spent many sleepless nights at the Sheraton Hotel in Damascus, then the city’s main social spot, kept awake by the boisterous up-till-dawn partying of the Syrian elite. Creepy indeed, in a police state. There were widespread doubts about Bashar, whether he had the necessary character to rule Syria, whether he had the guts.

Well, now we know. Bashar al-Assad seems every bit as willing as his father to destroy the country in order to save himself. In December, after Bashar’s military had killed its 5,000th fellow Syrian, the United Nations announced that it was no longer able to count the victims. (How many are there now?) Not long after, Bashar gave a speech ruthless enough to put a pit in your stomach. “Those states that counsel us to reform have no knowledge of democracy whatsoever,” he said. On the walls of the Sunni mosques, the ones he hasn’t ordered to be shelled, the government’s thugs scrawl: “Your God is Bashar.” In Hama, which came alive again after so many years, crowds carry placards: “Like Father, Like Son.”

Where does it end? Ajami leaves no doubt that the Assad family project, especially Bashar’s, was an essentially sectarian one. In this respect, Syria resembles its neighbors, Lebanon and Iraq, the former once ruled by a Christian minority, the latter by the minority Sunni Arabs. Remember what happened in those places? In Syria, the Alawites stand as a sort of palace guard, with everything to lose. (So far, very few have defected to the rebels.) It is not hard to imagine a fight to the death.

That dark prospect surely explains the reluctance of the Obama administration to try to stop Bashar’s killing machine, even as the Syrian rebels beg for our help. It’s too easy to envision an Iraqi-style blood bath after Bashar’s demise. Ajami is frustrated by Obama’s passivity, and indeed, as the killing goes on, it is getting harder for all of us to avert our eyes. Why is Syria different from Libya, where Obama and NATO, at very low cost, stopped an almost certain humanitarian disaster? Why is it different from Yugoslavia?

We may find out soon, whether we like it or not. As Ajami says, Bashar’s regime is in a race against itself. It must crush the rebellion before it ruins the economy. Even the Russians and the Chinese, faithful fellow oppressors, are embarrassed by the butchery. At some point, it seems likely, the regime will crack. It is then, and only then, that we will discover the true Syria, whether it was just an improbable creation set on the banks of the Euphrates, or a real nation after all.

Dexter Filkins is a staff writer at The New Yorker. He is the author of “The Forever War.”

The Syrian government increased attacks across the country, particularly in Homs, which sustained a massive shelling.

See this video made byاحمد حمادة who is shot while filming it…..

The United Nations’ human rights head recently said that government shelling of civilian areas amounts to war crimes. Opposition groups claim more than 14,000 civilians and 3,400 soldiers and militiamen loyal to Assad have been killed since the revolt began in March 2011.

Where is the Truth in the Battle for Syria’s Narrative,” by Sakhr al-Makhadhi

Obama fails to secure support from Putin on solution to Syria crisis
US president sought pledge against Bashar al-Assad at G20 summit, leaving Syria facing the prospect of increasing violence
Patrick Wintour in Los Cabos and Ewen MacAskill in Washington, guardian, Monday 18 June 2012

Barack Obama and Russia’s president Vladimir Putin completed a bilateral meeting on the margins of the G20 summit in Los Cabos, Mexico, on Monday with an agreement that there should be a cessation of hostilities in Syria.

But, crucially, Obama failed to secure the support of Putin for regime change in Syria. The US president had been seeking Putin’s help in trying to persuade Syrian president Bashar al-Assad to relinquish power and leave the country.

The author of the blog “China Matters” writes:

In case you haven’t caught it, Xinhua News Agency Damascus bureau is filing detailed reports (go to end of post) on a daily basis now after months of just regurgitating agency reports.  I think this represents a conscious decision by Assad and the Chinese to get the regime story out since nobody pays attention to SANA and the Western media coverage is heavily weighted toward opposition sources.  Similar thing going on with Russia’s RT Novosti.  As you may know, Xinhua has historically served as the party’s white intelligence and policy arm, especially in situations and jurisdictions where Chinese diplomats couldn’t operate freely.  So there’s more going on than just propaganda.

Russia Sending Missile Systems to Shield Syria
By ANDREW E. KRAMER, June 15, 2012

MOSCOW — Russia’s chief arms exporter said Friday that his company was shipping advanced defensive missile systems to Syria that could be used to shoot down airplanes or sink ships if the United States or other nations try to intervene to halt the country’s spiral of violence.

“I would like to say these mechanisms are really a good means of defense, a reliable defense against attacks from the air or sea,” Anatoly P. Isaykin, the general director of the company, Rosoboronexport, said Friday in an interview. “This is not a threat, but whoever is planning an attack should think about this.”

As the weapons systems are not considered cutting edge, Mr. Isaykin’s disclosures carried greater symbolic import than military significance. They contributed to a cold war chill that has been settling over relations between Washington and Moscow ahead a meeting between President Obama and President Vladimir V. Putin, their first, on the sidelines of the Group of 20 summit meeting in the Mexican resort of Los Cabos next week.

Russia and China Mull Syria … and Saudi Arabia, By Peter Lee

Robert Fisk, Nikolaos van Dam, and Russian specialist Anatol Lieven discuss the ongoing troubles in Syria – can world powers stop the killing? Colm Ó Mongáin on RTÉ Radio 1, 17 June 2012.


 NYTImes Blog photos of Syrian Uprising

Jerusalem Post: Kurds could hold key in Syria, 2012-06-18

In an effort to broaden its appeal among Syria’s diverse ethnic groups, the largest Syrian opposition group has selected a Kurd as its new leader. But it is not yet clear whether it will be enough to convince Kurdish political parties to be more …

Comments (158)

Pages: « 1 2 3 [4] Show All

151. Tara said:

I  am not clear to what was the brief suspension of the observers mission all about?  What has changed that made General Mood change his mind and stay?  

UN observers ‘committed to completing Syria mission despite coming under fire’
Maj Gen Mood did not attribute the suspension of the mission to any single incident, but said that among the issues was the inability of the observers to get through an angry crowd that mobbed their motorcade in the town of Haffa on June 12, when their motorcade was attacked by mobs with stones and metal rods and blocked by gunfire. The source of the gunfire was not clear.

The diplomat added that Mood told the council there has been little or no effort to ensure civilian protection by the Syrian government, and there has been no increase in the pace and scale of release of people who are arbitrarily detained.

Mood told the council, the diplomat said on condition of anonymity, that twice Syria announced the release of 500 detained persons, but the observers saw two groups of 230 and 100-plus released and few key leaders.

Mood said that on a smaller scale the opposition is depriving liberty to individuals too, the diplomat said.


Thumb up 7 Thumb down 9

June 20th, 2012, 10:48 am


152. Alan said:

Three Injured In Fresh Attacks Targeting Gaza
The Israeli Air Force carried out several airstrikes during the overnight and early dawn hours Wednesday targeting different parts of the Gaza Strip, leading to at least three injuries among the civilian population.
Local sources reported that at least one missile was fired at a car driving near Ali Ben Abi Taleb Mosque, in the az-Zeitoun neighborhood. No injuries were reported as the driver of the vehicle jumped out before impact.

The army also bombarded a blacksmith workshop in the neighborhood damaging the building and injuring one Palestinian.

A resistance training camp in the as-Sudaniyya area, near Gaza City, was also targeted by several missiles, while a similar attack targeted a training camp in Rafah, in the southern part of the Gaza Strip.

Eyewitnesses reported that the army also fired missiles at a group of resistance fighters east of Gaza City leading to two injuries.

On Wednesday morning, the army bombarded Wadi as-Salqa, south of Dir Aa-Balah, in central Gaza; a 17-year-old youth identified as Yahia Hattab was injuried.

On Tuesday evening, a Palestinian toddler, identified as Hadeel Ahmad al-Haddad, 2, was killed, while her brother suffered moderate injuries, and was moved to a local hospital for treatment.

Israeli missiles and shells targeting the Gaza Strip led to the death of 7 Palestinians, including two children, in the last 24 hours, dozens of injuries were reported; some were described as serious.

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 8

June 20th, 2012, 10:54 am


153. Ghufran said:

Both the regime and the opposition are lying about armed gangs activities and acts of thuggery that are terrorizing Syrians in most of Syria today. It is clear now that many of those crimes are not political,they are simply motivated by greed. The reason why Syria did not have this problem before is simple also: the army and security forces did not have to deal with armed rebels prior to march of 2011. In that sense,the uprising is directly linked to increased crimes in Syria,that does not equal blaming the opposition for everything that went wrong in Syria,that is what regime supporters want you to believe,one must ask what caused the uprising in the first place.

Thumb up 4 Thumb down 12

June 20th, 2012, 11:18 am


154. omen said:

the whole un observer concept is bigoted as hell if you ask me. what? syrians can’t be trusted to tell the truth? gee, there’s a pile of corpses, homs is decimated and regime put a ban on foreign reporters. complete mystery as to how this all happened.

give me a break.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 13

June 20th, 2012, 11:28 am


155. Alan said:

Tehran Countdown: Is no progress a failure?

Thumb up 7 Thumb down 10

June 20th, 2012, 11:40 am


156. zoo said:

Here we go, the genuine revolutionaries lured by the Brotherhood who will dump them when the MB gets back the power …

Egypt Brotherhood seeks to reunite with revolutionaries as new battle looms
The Muslim Brotherhood needs the support of revolutionaries as it braces for a fresh confrontation with Egypt’s ruling military
Hatem Maher, Wednesday 20 Jun 2012


Thumb up 5 Thumb down 8

June 20th, 2012, 1:40 pm


157. zoo said:

Regime and rebel forces to cease fire in Homs to allow evacuation – Red Cross

­Wounded and trapped civilians are preparing to be evacuated from Homs as the government and opposition forces agree to halt their fight, the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) said Wednesday. “The ICRC and the Syrian Arab Red Crescent are ready to enter the old city of Homs and the neighborhoods of Al-Qarabees, Al-Qusour, Jurat al-Shayyah and Al-Khalidiya as soon as possible,” the committee’s spokesperson told Reuters. The NGO will also deliver aid and medical supplies to Homs hospitals.

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 10

June 20th, 2012, 1:41 pm


158. anwar said:

Can the assad peons please stop whining about the revolution? boohoo they are lying and killing ? the opposition is divided ?? who would have thought things wouldn’t be perfect after 40 years of tyranny ?
man even if Jesus, Mohammed and budha were leading the revolution u would still be here nitpicking while assad murder them the same.

Thumb up 3 Thumb down 3

June 20th, 2012, 6:38 pm


Pages: « 1 2 3 [4] Show All

Post a comment