Upheaval within the Opposition: Defections, Terrorism, and Preparing for a Phase II Insurgency

The Syrian opposition is reshaping itself following its defeat in Homs. A new leadership seems bound to emerge. In all likelihood, in the new phase of the battle the is shaping up to combat the Assad regime, opposition leaders are likely to champion new tactics of militancy and Islamization.

The opposition will have to rebuild itself to be more Islamic, militant and sectarian in order to take on the Assad regime. Opposition leaders on the ground, those who are actually fighting the regime, have already become more militant and Islamized. If the SNC doesn’t scramble to catch up, it will become irrelevant. I suspect that the upcoming opposition meeting in Turkey this Thursday and Friday (March 22-23) will reflect some of that shift. The recent high level defections within the the Syrian National Council suggest the opposition is responding to these pressures and new demands. The SNC is going through a period of soul searching and transformation in response to the government’s classic “clear and hold” operations carried out in Sednaya, Homs and Idlib.

The future strategy of the Syrian opposition will have to follow the outlines of a classic “phase two” insurgency predicated on guerrilla warfare. This phase is reached when the insurgent movement initiates organized continuous guerrilla warfare in an attempt to push government forces into a defensive role. “Phase three” insurgency is a war of movement. In this phase the insurgent can directly engage government forces and hold territory. The Syrian opposition prematurely tried to hold territory and take on the Syrian Army. This was a bad and costly mistake. In the first year of the Syrian uprising the opposition naively believed that the entire Syrian population would embrace it and abandon the regime or that Bashar al-Assad would hand over power. Based on the example of the North African uprisings, Syrian opposition members incorrectly believed a “Tahrir Square  moment” would arrive within months of the uprising’s start, eliminating the need for a coherent military strategy, a defined leadership, or how to parry government counter-insurgency operations. The passions of Syrians who have tasted little but contempt from their own government led them to rise up in an act of incredible courage. Now, however, the reality of just how difficult attaining victory will be is setting in.

The Assad regime remains vigorous and will last longer than many thought. The reason that mass defections have not destroyed the regime are twofold: sectarian anxieties prevent Alawite defections, and the regime turns out to be more sectarian than many thought; and class anxieties are more important as well.

Members of the Sunni middle and upper classes are not defecting in the numbers the opposition hoped that they would. The reason that neither Damascus or Aleppo have become centers of the revolution is usually attributed to their privileged position in Syrian society. Wealthy Sunnis living in the West have joined the revolution, but that may be because they do not fear the disorder and incompetence of the opposition in the same way as those living in Syria. They have also experienced the freedom and dignity afforded by the rule of law. They look at the brutality of the Assad regime and wonder, “how come we  have this?”

The Syrian revolutionaries are largely rural and young, just as were the Baathists in the 1960s. Wealthy and educated Sunnis fear the results of the present revolution could be the same for them as the results of the last revolution, when Syria’s rural poor took power. They will lose money, status and their quality of life, at least temporarily. If the Lebanon and Iraq revolutions are a guide, that decline could last a long time.

The coming “phase II” insurgency will be characterized by:

  1. the creation of cell-networks that maintain secrecy
  2. Terrorism: these techniques include bombings, assassinations, kidnappings, threats, mutilation, murder, torture, and blackmail. These actions will be used to provoke the government into overreactions that discredit the regime, alienate the populace, and demonstrate its inability to protect them.
  3. multifaceted attempts to cultivate support in the general population, by undermining the regime, proving that the opposition must be feared and will eventually win, and by winning gratitude and trust by providing food and shelter to those in need.
  4. attacks against the government and security forces, such as car bombings in Damascus and Aleppo and the planting of IEDs as in Iraq and Afghanistan will undermine military moral and its ability to move around the country.

In order for the opposition to organize an effective phase II insurgency, it will have to embrace guerrilla warfare and greater Islamization of the resistance. This means  Sunni sectarian recruitment, Islamic martyrdom operations, and all the aspects of Middle Eastern insurgency that we have seen used so effectively against occupation forces in the recent past, whether used by Palestinians, Afghans or Iraqis. Elements of the SNC who are unhappy with the way the Ghalioun has

The role of Burhan Ghalioun and members of the Syrian National Council closest to him, such as Ausama Monajed and Bassma Kodmadi, is bound to diminish or change in the coming phase of the struggle. They must be prepared to embrace a much more stridently Sunni insurgency. The regime has proven its viciousness.  The secular leaders of the SNC have been very successful at mobilizing the West against Assad. They have gotten sanctions put in place and the regime has been isolated internationally. But they look down on religion and warfare.

Kamal Labwani, a leader of the Syrian opposition who quit the Syrian National Council last week, accused the SNC of being an “autocratic” organization that has sidelined most of its members. “There is no council, it’s an illusion,” he said. Furthermore he accused council chief Burhan Ghalioun of being like Bashar and “running the organization …. [like] Assad’s ruling Baath party.” Haytham Mallah slammed Ghalioun for being reluctant to support the military effort of the Free Syrian Army. Anwar al-Bunni is worried that the Muslim Brotherhood has become too powerful within the SNC. These are all growing pains as the opposition struggles to keep up with the changes on the ground brought on by the Homs crisis and opposition defeat.

In keeping with the Islamization necessary to recruit financial and military assistance for the revolution, opposition organizers in the West are rallying support from the broader Islamic community by presenting the Syrian struggle in clear religious terms. Quoting from the Koran is key to this. Here are selected quotes from a recent Syrian opposition rally held in Australia. Notice the use of Islamic concepts of martydom, khalifa, the umma, rejection of nationalism, angles coming to the aid of Islamic fighters, blood nourishing the roots of Jihad, etc.

Sunni Shaykhs of Australia Speak at Rally to Gather Support against the Assad Regime

This is a video of the Muslim community protest for Syria held on Jan 21, 2012 at Paul Keating Park, Bankstown, Sydney, Australia. This video is of the entire protest, including all talks, chanting and videos. The following are snippets of the talks:

“We Stand United for the Sake of Allah and for our Brothers and Sisters who are Getting Slaughtered – We are all Muslims who are Worshiping Allah.” “We Ask Allah to Destroy the Assad Regime and his army.” The Muslim Umma stands as one. For one hundred years these dictatorships and these animals have reigned. … The Umma is one step closer to realizing the reality… the reality of the Khilafa to come. Put your trust in Allah. Allah ordains that our brothers and sisters in Syria stand firm, brave and courageous in standing against those who have been oppressing them for the past decades. We can see the wings of angles above Damascus. They will destroy Assad and his regime. Allah insists that his life will continue to exist and the light of his martyrs will continue and the only thing that will be destroy is the life of tyrants and the Assad regime and his army and to revive truth as he promised. God has made us one Umma. It is the Umma of God who is one.”

Remember that the blood of the Martyrs will never be wasted. It will continue to feed the roots of the tree. The prophet said that their will remain a group of my Umma who will fight on the command of Allah to suppress evil and uphold the unity of God.  Brothers in Islam, to remember that the outcome is for the beliefs. The outcome is for the beliefs. to remember the stance of the people of tawhiid. We had our Umma and our scholars stand up for belief against these regimes. When the likes of al-Buti and the likes of al-Hassoun, this dog wearing a turban, stood on the side of the tyrants. Remember that victory will only come with adhering to the book of Allah and his Sunna. Victory will NOTcome with the name of nationalism. Lift your fingers in the direction of God and say there is only one God. Oh Muslims of Syria Victory is near.


Al Arabiya: Al Arabiya declined to publish Assad’s ‘very personal emails’

None of the “very personal emails” of President Bashar al-Assad or his wife Asmaa al-Akhras were aired or published, Al Arabiya said on Friday. The pan-Arab news channel said that many “private” messages were in their inbox among thousands … Al Arabiya said that none of the emails were exchanged with senior military or government officials in the country. There weren’t any exchange of emails with members of the Assad family as well, but most of emails were exchanged with members of his wife’s family and his close friends who belonged to his inner circle….Hundreds of “scandalous” emails were accordingly deleted by Al Arabiya.

Bashar Al Assad’s Wife ‘Could Face Two Year Prison Term’ for Sanctions Busting After Shopping Spree – March 16 (Telegraph)

Syria: Bashar Al-Assad Email Reveals Mystery Near Naked Woman
by Raf Sanchez, March 16 (Telegraph) —

Mystery surrounds a photograph of an near-naked woman posing provocatively that was sent to Bashar al-Assad by a young female political aide. The undated picture shows the woman, clad only in white lingerie, pressing herself against a wall as her clothes lie discarded in a heap at her feet. It was discovered among thousands of emails from the personal accounts of the Syrian president and his wife after their passwords were smuggled out of Damascus by opposition groups. The photograph was sent to Mr Assad on December 11 last year by Hadeel al-Ali,

John Stewart: Homs Despot: Syrian dictator Bashar al Assad’s hacked emails reveal he’ll taunt NATO in the world community, but he won’t f**k with Apple.

Syria: Songs of Defiance – Al Jazeera.Net

An undercover Al Jazeera correspondent takes us inside the lives of Syria’s anti-government demonstrators.

Syria Puts On Mass Rally in Support of Assad
By ANNE BARNARD in the New York Times

“What happened in Homs is betrayal,” Mr. Labwani said in an interview. “There is a sense of irresponsibility on the part of the council.”

The council, he added, was in danger of causing splits in Syrian society by failing to create a single rebel military command under its control, leaving individual militias to seek their own sources of help. He accused Muslim Brotherhood members within the exile opposition of “monopolizing funding and military support.”

The 270-member council has been plagued by internal disagreements. A member of its executive committee, Samir Nachar, played down the latest frictions, saying the members had not submitted formal resignations. One, he said, was simply frustrated at his exclusion from a meeting with the United Nations special envoy, Kofi Annan. Mr. Nachar said Mr. Labwani had attended few meetings.

Mr. Nachar acknowledged the council needed to improve but said disagreements were inevitable, noting that many members had never met before the uprising and had widely varying backgrounds and opinions.

But this time the departing members include some well-known figures with deep credibility among Syrians both inside and outside the country, including Mr. Labwani and Haitham Maleh, an executive committee member and lawyer in his 80s who served many years in prison after defending Syrian dissidents, including Muslim Brotherhood members.

Mr. Maleh could not be reached for comment, but told Al Jazeera that he had resigned because of chaos within the group and doubt over what it could accomplish, adding, “We have not gotten very far in working to arm the rebels.”

Still, the way forward for the opposition seemed unclear. On Tuesday, the Syrian National Council had taken steps to bring the Free Syrian Army under its umbrella. But Mr. Labwani, the council member who is resigning, said the exiles had few ties to the fighters inside. “The Free Syrian Army is the people who are inside Syria,” he said.

He called the council’s head, Burhan Ghalioun, an autocrat who makes decisions “under our names without getting back to us.” Mr. Ghalioun could not be reached for comment.

Mr. Labwani said he had argued that the rebels should be armed only under a single command with the council controlling the finances, but Muslim Brotherhood members had objected.

“It will lead to disaster, especially if the revolution is turned into militias,” Mr. Labwani said.

The other two resigning members are Walid al-Bunni and Catherine Altalli. “The Brotherhood took the whole council,” Mr. Bunni said in an interview. “We became like extras.”

In a kind of warning, Mr. Labwani and Mr. Maleh last month formed a new group under the council’s umbrella.

Tony Karon in Time

…. Looking at the balance of forces on the ground, it’s not hard to see why [Assad] may be feeling lucky, at least in the near term. In recent weeks, he has sent armored units to recapture rebel-held neighborhoods first in Homs and then in Idlib. Having successfully driven opposition fighters outside of those areas they had held for months, he has turned his forces’ attention back to Deraa in the south, cradle of the rebellion. Of course, these operations have exacted a terrible toll in civilian life and suffering, not sufficient to prompt foreign powers capable of intervening to throw off the restraints they have imposed on themselves out of fear of the consequences of plunging into a messy civil war…..

Syrian rebels lack guns, money after key defeats
By ELIZABETH A. KENNEDY | Associated Press

BEIRUT (AP) — Two significant defeats at the hands of Syrian government troops have exposed the limitations of the country’s rebel forces: They are low on cash, running out of weapons and facing a fiercely loyal military that will fight to the death.

Insisting that their drive to oust President Bashar Assad by force remains strong, the Free Syrian Army says the arms shortage is the main obstacle.

“Send us money, we’re desperate. Send us weapons,” Ahmad Kassem, who coordinates military operations for the FSA, told The Associated Press in an interview. “We don’t need fighters. We have excess men who can fight, but we need weapons to protect our land and honor.”(..)

Saudi Arabia shut down its embassy in Damascus, the Saudi foreign ministry announced Wednesday. Saudi Arabia and other Gulf monarchies withdrew their ambassadors in February.

Assad Tells Annan he has three conditions for Cease Fire,”  Shamlife, Thursday, March 15, 2012

  • Armed groups must promise to cease fire
  • Neighboring countries must promise to stop the smuggling of weapons into Syria
  • Countries must promise to stop financing the opposition

علمت صحيفة “النهار” ان “رد الرئيس بشار الاسد على المبعوث المشترك للامم المتحدة وجامعة الدول العربية كوفي أنان في سوريا، تضمن ثلاثة شروط هي، تعهد المجموعات المسلحة وقف النار، تعهد دول الجوار وقف تهريب الرجال والسلاح، وتعهد الدول الممولة للمعارضة وقف تمويلها”. وعندما تتحقق هذه الشروط يوقف الرئيس الأسد العمليات العسكرية ضد المسلحين.

A Chrisian friend from Homs writes of how refugee families are occupying empty apartments.

My family left Homs because of their fear for their lives, some went to Damascus and some to Lebanon and few families went to Marmarita and Amar AL Huson,

My cousin who went to her Daughter in AL Raga, went back to Homs and found people in her house, it is 2 bedroom house so she told them that she needs the house as it is too small for more than her and her family, so they left, another relative of mine in Hameedia, they left first then when they came back they found people in their home so they asked them to leave, they refused and asked the owners my relative to talk to the office in one of the Hameedia restaurant that is occupied , so they went there and asked for their house back, they complied and the office of the armed militia ( i think) asked the people who were staying in the house to leave and give the house back, apparently they occupied the houses of the people who left, I am not sure if they forced the people out, that is what i heard from my family.

Google Ideas Director Involved in ‘Regime Change’

Explosive news: Ex-State Department employee tuned Google director pushes programs supporting regime change in the Middle East. This comes on the back of news that Avaaz’s campaign manager is also ex-State Dept. This really begs the question whether there is a policy decision to infiltrate social media at the top as well. Disturbing stuff…..

Syria’s rebels will have to deal with Assad
By Julien Barnes-Dacey
Senior Policy Fellow, Middle East and North Africa Programme, European Council on Foreign Relations, www.ecfr.eu

No one wants to deal with dictators. But one year after the Syrian uprising began, the harsh truth is that Bashar al-Assad maintains the upper hand and the opposition – with its international backers – may have little choice but to cut a deal with him if they want to ease the Syrian people’s suffering.

Through brutal suppression, cynical sectarian mobilisation and continued support from Russia and Iran, the regime has maintained its grip on power. Mr Assad has lost most of his legitimacy and Syria’s economy is crumbling but, so long as the regime has internal cohesion and external support, it is unlikely to collapse soon. The headlines accorded the recent defection of a powerless deputy minister have only served to highlight the struggle facing the opposition.

Short of unlikely direct foreign intervention, the worst scenario Mr Assad faces is prolonged civil war, particularly if foreign powers arm the opposition as demanded by the Syrian National Council and Free Syrian Army. But without artillery and air support, the balance of power is unlikely to change quickly. Moreover, while this route could eventually help the rebels to a military victory, it may further empower Mr Assad among his internal and external backers, by providing a justification for regime violence. The one certainty is that an already horrific toll will increase exponentially, as it did in civil wars in Iraq and Lebanon.

From a humanitarian perspective, then, it is urgent to find a political solution….

For Russia – as well as China and even Iran – to change tack and to press Mr Assad to implement a ceasefire, the opposition will have to consent to direct talks with the regime, not preconditioned on Mr Assad’s immediate departure or on that of regime forces from urban centres. In effect, the initial price will be an outcome that favours the regime’s position on the ground. Distasteful as this will be, there is no other way to end the bloodshed. However, if Mr Assad was to agree a ceasefire, even if he remains in power, he will be far more marginalised internationally and under severe pressure to comply. Such an outcome could ease the entry of humanitarian aid and of a new, enhanced team of monitors.

More positively, such a deal could prepare the ground for a political process, however difficult, that could swing the balance in the opposition’s favour. After four decades of repression, a vibrant, politically mobilised population is now intent on seizing its own future. The state of fear has been broken. This is a force Mr Assad is unable to resist except by violence. A political track may therefore be a surer way of ultimately ending the regime.

The regime could of course renew its violence, but commitments by Syria’s protectors – principally Russia and China – to the process, as well as continuing western economic and political pressure, would make it harder for Mr Assad to extricate himself. A political process could also help erode internal support by persuading senior Alawites to support the Arab League transition plan, under which Mr Assad would step down. It should be remembered that Yemen’s transition plan only succeeded on the basis of talks with President Abdullah Saleh.

While the SNC and FSA reject talks with the regime, many Syrians – including activists – already think political dialogue is the best means of averting a devastating civil war. It should be the west’s preference too.

Date: 19 February 2012 07:41:51 GMT
From: CF2R Secrétariat <info@cf2r.org>
You’ll find here attached our latest report, THE LEBANONIZATION OF SYRIA. Report on the actors of the Syrian crisis, Paris, January 2012.

Organised at the instigation of the Centre Français de Recherche sur le Renseignement (French Center for Intelligence Studies – CF2R) and the Centre international de recherche et d’études sur le terrorisme et d’aide aux victimes du terrorisme (International Center for Research and Study on Terrorism and Aid to Victims of Terrorism – CIRET-AVT), an international delegation of experts travelled to Syria from December 3rd to December 10th, 2011, in order to assess the situation in Syria in an independent and impartial manner and to meet with the actors of this nine-month-long crisis. It completed its assessment mission with meetings with various representatives of the Syrian opposition abroad, as well as with a panel of Middle East experts from Europe.
The aim of the present report is to provide objective information on a crisis which is being substantially deformed by the control that Syria’s adversaries have over international media networks.
The media networks of the Gulf states, with support from major Anglo-American press agencies and their European and French counterparts, have become frontline players in this crisis, with « global » coverage aimed primarily at the overthrow of the Damascus regime, similar to what occurred in Libya.
This falsification of the facts seeks to hide from global public opinion the support – often reluctant – that the majority of the Syrian population have for the current regime and the fact that the external opposition is not the most legitimate stakeholder (as opposed to longstanding domestic opposition groups), neither do they espouse democratic ideals that they pretend to promote (given their strongly Islamist character).
By Robert D. Kaplan | March 14, 2012
…The Arab Spring has periodically been compared to the stirrings of 1848. But with the exception of the toppling of the Orleans monarchy in France, the 1848 revolutions ultimately failed. Dynastic governments reasserted themselves. They did so for a reason that has troubling implications for the Middle East: Conservative regimes in mid-19th century Europe had not only the institutional advantage over their liberal and socialist adversaries but also the moral advantage….

 If conservative — even reactionary — orders are necessary for inter-communal peace, then they may survive in one form or another, or at least resurface in places such as Egypt and Iraq. Iraq in 2006 and 2007 proved that chaos is in some respects worse than tyranny. Thus, a system is simply not moral if it cannot preserve domestic peace. “Progress includes Order,” John Stuart Mill wrote in Considerations on Representative Government (1861), “but Order does not include Progress.” In other words, nobody is saying that conservative-reactionary orders will lead to social betterment. Nonetheless, because order is necessary before progress can take hold, reactionary regimes could be the beneficiary of chaos in some Middle Eastern states, in a similar way that the Habsburgs were after 1848. For it is conservative regimes of one type or another that are more likely to be called upon to restore order…..

While Syria’s al Assad is seen as illegitimate, that does not mean that the future in Syria automatically means either democracy or sectarian chaos. It may mean eventually a new form of authoritarianism that alleviates or better manages such instability in the first place. Remember that a system is not defined by the name it gives itself, but by how the power relationships actually work behind the scenes. Thus, Iraq may call itself a democracy, but in truth it is a sectarian “thugocracy” that barely keeps order, and if it continues to falter in that regard, it may eventually be replaced by a full-fledged authoritarian regime (hopefully one far less brutal than Saddam Hussein’s).

Indeed, democratic uprisings in 1848 did not secure democracy, they merely served notice that society had become too restive and too complex for the existent monarchical regimes to insure both order and progress. In Political Order in Changing Societies (1968), Harvard political scientist Samuel Huntington wrote that the more complex a society becomes, the greater the number of institutions that are required to govern it.

So one should not confuse the formation of new regimes in the Middle East with their actual consolidation. This will require coercive power in the form of new police forces and intelligence agencies, notes Antonio Giustozzi of the London School of Economics in his provocative new book, The Art of Coercion (2011). And such extreme forms of compulsion are only alleviated by the building of civilian institutions of the kind Huntington talks about, which can then maintain order in a more benign manner. If new bureaucratic institutions do not emerge in a more socially complex Middle East, the Arab Spring will be a false one, and it will be remembered like 1848.

Meanwhile, the authoritarianism of the al-Saud family lingers on in Saudi Arabia, the strategic linchpin of the Arabian Peninsula. And lesser monarchs from Kuwait south to Oman appear not to be in danger. With the exception of the oppressed Shia in Bahrain and in eastern Saudi Arabia, the peoples of the Persian Gulf still broadly associate stability and progress with conservative orders. Thus, the emirs and sultans have the loyalty of their populations and hence the moral advantage.

Syria is at this very moment a bellwether. It is afflicted by ethnic and sectarian splits — Sunnis versus Shia-trending Alawites versus Druze and Kurds. But Syria also can claim historical coherence as an age-old cluster of cosmopolitanism at the crossroads of the desert and the Mediterranean, a place littered with the ruins of Byzantine and medieval Arab civilizations. The Western intelligentsia now equate a moral outcome in Syria with the toppling of the present dictator, who requires those sectarian splits to survive. But soon enough, following the expected end of al Assad’s regime, a moral outcome will be associated with the re-establishment of domestic order and the building of institutions coercive or not. Because only with that can progress be initiated.

1848 had tragic repercussions: While democracy in Europe flowered briefly following World War I, it was snuffed out by fascism and then communism. Thus, 1848 had to wait until 1989 to truly renew itself. Because of technology’s quickened advance, political change is faster in the Middle East. But for 2011 to truly be remembered as the year of democracy in the Arab world, new forms of non-oppressive order will first have to be established. And with the likely exception of Tunisia — a country close to Europe with no ethnic or sectarian splits — that appears for the moment to be problematic.

Five myths about Syria,” by Roger Owen in Wash Post

5. The international community has to do something to stop the violence…. As the recent history of such interventions demonstrates, the desire to put an end to what are regarded as the evil policies of an evil regime can easily cause politicians to neglect the other side of the balance sheet: the number of civilian lives that will undoubtedly be lost in the attempt to save them. Think, for example, of the hundreds of thousands of Afghans who’ve been widowed since the Russian invasion some 30 years ago.

Hands On Syria, Hands Off Iran
Martin van Creveld, Jason Pack, 14 Mar 12

CommentsCAMBRIDGE – Israel is daily ratcheting up its threats to attack Iran over its nuclear program. Unfortunately, these threats have come to overshadow more pressing events in Syria, which is the epicenter of a regional crisis that will determine the future of the Arab Spring, as well as Iran’s role in the Middle East….. The Israeli government has vastly exaggerated the threat that a nuclear Iran poses to its security, …. The ascendant powers in the Middle East are Turkey and Qatar. These Sunni countries, along with Saudi Arabia, should join with their international allies and initiate a regional solution to Syria’s crisis. …..Now is not the time to provoke Iran, but rather to tend to Syria’s troubles before it is too late – for example, by publicly offering Assad a way out of the country that will safeguard the minority Alawite community if he is toppled or forced to flee. If the Syria situation is ignored, its spillover may inadvertently provoke Israeli or Iranian action, inciting a regional war and a global depression.

Amnesty International’s latest report ‘I wanted to die’: Syria’s torture survivors speak out

Iraq Lets Iran Fly Arms to Syria Despite U.S. Protests
By: Kristina Wong | The Washington Times

The Iraqi government has refused U.S. requests to stop Iranian cargo flights to Syria, despite being aware of credible intelligence that the planes are transporting up to 30 tons of weapons, according to a U.S. official.

Syria Marks Anniversary of Uprising Against Assad
By: Patrick J. McDonnell and Paul Richter | Los Angeles Times

A year after the revolt began, President Bashar Assad shows no sign of easing his grip on power. Rebels have no plans to back down, leaving Syria at an impasse.

Comments (900)

Pages: « 18 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 [18] Show All

851. Jad said:

سلوى يا سلوى ليش عما تبكي
بددي صديقتي
اومي نئي يللي بديك يا
حلوة بشعة حلوة بشعة حلوة
Hopefully good days are ahead for Syria’s children.

Thumb up 11 Thumb down 0

March 23rd, 2012, 11:28 am


852. majedkhaldoun said:

You said
“Nusayri is not the name chosen by Alawites to describe themselve. Nusayri is used as a term of denigration if not a curse”

You can not be further fom the truth, I heared and read several of them call theselve Nusayri I refer you to books written by Ziki Al Arsuzi, and even Joshua Landis mentioned Nusayri several times in the past, you must correct this statement.
Please note that the word Alawi was added in 1920 as they were called also Alawi by the french, many of them still call themselve Nusayri.

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 13

March 23rd, 2012, 11:31 am


853. Tara said:



Thumb up 6 Thumb down 7

March 23rd, 2012, 11:34 am


854. majedkhaldoun said:

Many in SC say Salafist or wahhabi in a denegrating term, if you ban Nusayri because it imply dengration then you must ban the use of salafist or wahhabi.

You use Islamist and you explained it that you mean Sunni, Islam has many branches, it is obvious to you that all mosslems are Sunni, and thus salafist or wahhabi.

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 11:43 am


855. Michel said:

I’m greek orthodox christian from saidnaya and I want to personally torture Assad and his wife for what they have done to the country, their lies, their use of the minorities to protect the regime.

Thumb up 10 Thumb down 14

March 23rd, 2012, 11:44 am


856. irritated said:

#855 Michel

“I’m greek orthodox christian from saidnaya and I want to personally torture Assad and his wife”

I congratulate you for expressing your “christian” beliefs so frankly.
BTW, it is not “saidnaya’ but “saydnaya’

Thumb up 13 Thumb down 7

March 23rd, 2012, 11:54 am


857. Uzair8 said:

716. Uzair8 said:

“This is an interesting battle. A clash of 2 opposite strategies.

‘Cracking a nut with a sledgehammer’ V ‘Dea.th by a thousand cuts’ ”

Expanding on this theme.

The first, the regime strategy, is ineffective and only ends up harming civilians, potentialy angering and forcing more of them and other Syrian onlookers into the arms of the opposition.

The second, the opposition strategy, needs time and may take longer if the regime allies continue to help patch up its wounds.

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 11

March 23rd, 2012, 11:55 am



Need Help
I think you have a fine taste, Do you think this is a classy enough gift for Asma Al-Assad? . Believe me I searched for the most expensive and best…Her Birthday is not until August 11. Please read the reviews, they are excellent.

P.S., Please note that I am a utilitarian rat with my gifts, I like to send gifts with practical use.

Also, I would appreciate your response soon, I have only a short time before Mr. Assad’s snipers realize that I am out of my rat hole and aim at me. They have just shot my neighbor, a beautiful and proud goose. The poor thing was staying only for short time during his migration. I heard the sniper shout Batta only or we burn the whole steppes , just after my neighbor fell down.


Thumb up 9 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 11:56 am


859. Michel said:


No other dialogue possible with this criminal regime.

What amazes me is that some people are defending this regime and denying thing that no syrians would have argued with for the past 41 years up until the last year. All of a sudden, this is a good regime that cares about syrians. Ha ha ha!

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 12

March 23rd, 2012, 11:57 am


860. mjabali said:

Majedkhaldoun has been cursing the Alswis in almost every post he mentioned them since day one. He is not the first or the last. Many harness the same feeling but few of them dare to say it like Majedkhaldoun here on Syria Comment.

Some of them try to mask it but their true snotty attitude towards the Alawis seeps through their texts here and there.

The other day a new commentator called the Alawis “slugs.” This shows you how Syrians really view each others.

Alawis had been used to this relentless campaign of smear and degradation throughout their history. Look at the hatred that is written about the Alawis all over the internet. You will be disgusted.

Tho amount of this hate literature against the Alawis on the net alone is tremendous and growing by the day. You can go and look at it on You Tube, Facebook, al-Arabiyah, Elaph….etc Anywhere you turn you see this literature which really indicates a sick populace. This sick mentally has existed for the last 700 or so years.

Alawis normally do not respond. They rarely do.

Many times Majedkhaldoun was told that using this term “Nusayri” is not kosher but he insisted on using it over and over.

But, I say that is his FREEDOM of speech and let him say whatever he wants.

Syria now needs the truth and what Majedkhaldoun says is the true feeling and attitude of many. Moderation here is not going to stop people from talking like that.

Moderation should not stop us to see how “educated” people look at minorities and others.

The truth about how we feel is what is going to solve matters correctly.

Moderation in this blog is a hard task, but, we, commentators, should be left free to say whatever we want.

Freedom of speech please.

Thumb up 10 Thumb down 3

March 23rd, 2012, 11:59 am


861. irritated said:

Uzair8 #857

It could as well be, using your sentences:

“The second, the opposition strategy, needs time.. is ineffective and only ends up harming civilians, potentialy angering and forcing more of them and other Syrian onlookers into the arms of the ‘regime'”

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 12:00 pm


862. Uzair8 said:

#858 SH

Asma’s birthday is on Aug 11th. That would be in the last 10 days of Ramadan.

Perhaps by then the Assad’s will be opening their ‘fast’ (and celebrating her birthday) in prison with prison food.

Thumb up 4 Thumb down 9

March 23rd, 2012, 12:01 pm


863. Michel said:


Are you serious?

Saidnaya, Saydnaya, Sednaya, all are used since there’s more than one way of romanizing arabic. What’s your point exactly? Wikipedia has it listed as Saidnaya, Im not sure what your point is.

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 12:02 pm


864. irritated said:

#860 Michel

“Ha ha ha!”

I don’t find that funny, really.. Try a joke.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 7

March 23rd, 2012, 12:03 pm


865. irritated said:

864. Michel

I see, you found it in Wikipedia.
The official website that you probably never visited is


Thumb up 8 Thumb down 7

March 23rd, 2012, 12:06 pm


866. Son of Damascus said:



I guess you should tell the restaurant to fix their name as well.

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 12:07 pm


867. jad said:

Is Wahhabi terrorism bad in France, good in Syria?

In mid March a Wahhabi fanatic attacked a Shiite mosque in Brussels and killed the imam. A week later it was time for the Wahhabis to strike again. Mohammad Mehra, a young Frenchman of Algerian origin killed seven people. Three children were among the victims.

The murderer then barricaded himself in his apartment until he suddenly decided to jump out of a window. As he was falling he got sprayed with bullets by the hundreds of police who were besieging the building.

President Sarkozy condemned the acts with very harsh words. Rightly so. The problem is that Sarkozy, while going after Wahhabi terrorists at home, supports them in Syria. This is what makes his moral stance questionable.
In fact “Al-Qaida”, or rather “Qaidism” since it is more of a way of thinking than an organization, is just another expression of Saudi Islam or Wahhabism. The Wahhabis, or Salafis as they call themselves, are divided into several groups but they all share a common world view, which includes a strong element of “internal Islamophobia”.

By that I refer to their understanding of themselves as the only saved sect and their virulent rejection of other Muslims, especially Sufi oriented Sunnis and Shiites. This “internal Islamophobia” means that they demonize all other Muslims and dismiss most of the great Mystics, Theologians and Philosophers of the past.
If you play with fire you might get burned and Wahhabi terrorism on your own back yard is much more unpleasant than watching the Syrian people suffer from a distance. But once the wild dogs of Wahhabism are unleashed anything can happen.
I know that morals do not mean much do politicians but I call on Sarkozy to contemplate the pain of Syrian mothers. To kill children is a bestial act, whether in France or in Syria, whether in Toulouse or in Homs. The pain of Syrian mothers, who have lost their children to Wahhabi terrorists, is no different from the pain of French mothers, whose children were shot by Mehra.

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 3

March 23rd, 2012, 12:08 pm


868. Michel said:


Here comes the “you’re not a christian and you’re not from saidnaya since you can’t be christian and be against this regime” part of the show I guess

Nice argumentative tactic 😉

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 12:08 pm


869. Alan said:

please alan.abdo@yandex.ru

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 12:10 pm


870. jad said:

The terrorists of ‘Tora Bora’ Jihadist in Syria:
مجموعة كبيرة لارهابين في سوريا بطلقون على انفسهم جهاديين يقومون بقطع الطرق وبتفجير وتلغيم الطرق العامة – عمليات اغلبها مرتكزة في ادلب
وببحضور لعناصر غربية ( اجانب )

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 2

March 23rd, 2012, 12:11 pm


871. Michel said:


how about this ? http://saidnaya.com/ the people who made this website are all liars!!

Alright, I’ll play the game
You’re not even syrian and you’ve never been to syria, because if you were syrian you would know that the name of places on the signs on the roads are not romanized in the same way. For example you can see “Ommayad” on one sign, and “Ummayad” on one 2 minutes away from the first one. You should know that, but obviously you don’t, therefore you’re not syrian!

see what I did there?

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 9

March 23rd, 2012, 12:21 pm


872. irritated said:

After the UN statement has been accepted by the international community, the anti-regime on SC are now divided in three groups:

A group has a repeated urge to torture and kill Bashar and his wife.
A group has sudden bursts of religious faith and identity and want to silence all the ‘heretics’ and ‘infidels’ from Syria.
A group is looking for a present for Asma’s birthday and more gossips.

I wonder how can this be interpreted.

Thumb up 11 Thumb down 3

March 23rd, 2012, 12:23 pm


873. irritated said:

872. Michel

…and you are not even christian…

Anyone can be against the regime but acts of sadism and revenge are certainly not christian.

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 12:27 pm


874. Michel said:


how about this ? https://www.facebook.com/SRCSMMM

They’ve written Saidnaya!!! They’re liars !!! 😉

Thumb up 2 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 12:27 pm


875. irritated said:


Are you trying desperately to convince me that you are from صيدنايا

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 3

March 23rd, 2012, 12:31 pm


876. Michel said:

By your concept we would have to say that muslims who drink alcohol or don’t pray five times a day are not muslims.

If you’re willing to accept that (otherwise it would be a double-standard), then sure I’m “not a christian”.


Thumb up 3 Thumb down 9

March 23rd, 2012, 12:31 pm


877. Halabi said:

It seems we all agree that calling the opposition, which includes Sunnis, Alawites, Christians, atheists and everything between as 3ara3eer, a term the opposition doesn’t use, is considered a racist slur. (Using the N-word so liberally is also a sign of racial insensitivity).

On another note, Rami Makhlouf has allegedly pledged to rebuild all the destroyed areas in Syria. Can anyone who isn’t delusional imagine him cutting a ribbon in Baba Amr anytime soon?

Thumb up 4 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 12:33 pm


878. Michel said:

Not trying to convince you at all, I don’t care really what you think. I’m just trying to show you how silly and dumb you look by trying to pick on the way I’ve written it in my first post. Apart from that, feel free to think im not from saidnaya or that im not a christian 😉

Thumb up 2 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 12:33 pm


879. irritated said:


You seem to know better about Islam than you know about Christianity.
Maybe you should go and read the teachings of Jesus-Christ before promoting torture on anyone.
In your area, there are plenty of priests and nuns who could correct you in your way of thinking.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 12:35 pm


880. Tara said:

Dear Hamster

I think it makes a great gift.  I  like its multi-usage features.  It has a low pitch tone and a high pitch scream.

I specifically like the law sultry pitch to coax and comfort when Batta is physically close especially after letting her indulge in a shopping while killing spree…. But let’s not forget, the high-pitch scream she would need to use declaring herself “the real dictator”.  Ah.. Tara’s  wild imagination.  

All in all, it makes a racy statement.

Be safe, Hamster

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 10

March 23rd, 2012, 12:37 pm


881. Alan said:

all are under hypnosis of sectarian accessory! Bernard Lewis is effective!

Thumb up 7 Thumb down 5

March 23rd, 2012, 12:39 pm


882. Alan said:

Moderator ! pls there is a personality insult in comments above!

Thumb up 1 Thumb down 3

March 23rd, 2012, 12:43 pm


883. Uzair8 said:

862. irritated said:

Uzair8 #857

It could as well be, using your sentences:

“The second, the opposition strategy, needs time.. is ineffective and only ends up harming civilians, potentialy angering and forcing more of them and other Syrian onlookers into the arms of the ‘regime’”


I respectfully disagree. The potential consequences of the regime’s ‘nut/sledgehammer’ approach are obvious.

However the opposition/FSA ‘Dea.th by a 1000 cuts’ strategy reflects an incisive and precision based approach designed to avoid or minimise the affect on civilians.

The opposition will continue to chip away at the regime.
You can even call it the ‘straw that broke the camel’s back’ strategy.

Thumb up 1 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 12:44 pm


884. Son of Damascus said:


Please point me where in the teachings of Jesus Christ he spoke about the “cleanup and disinfection” of entire neighbourhoods.

Maybe before you take a holier than thou attitude against someone (that might have not been aware of your earlier comments), you should express to us how disgusting and utterly wrong to say such a thing?

Or is killing in the name of Bashar exempted for you?

Michel if you are not aware here is the link to what I am talking about:

Thumb up 4 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 12:48 pm


885. Son of Damascus said:

“all are under hypnosis of sectarian accessory! Bernard Lewis is effective!”

You figured us all out!!!! We even have a song about it… Heres the hook

Bernie Bernie Bernie Cant you see

Sometimes your words just hypnotize me

And we just Love your zionist ways (huh)

Guess thats why they are broke, and you so paid (huh)

Thumb up 3 Thumb down 8

March 23rd, 2012, 1:00 pm


886. jad said:


The moment anybody comes here regardless what the name is and identify themselves according to their ‘SECT’ not even their religion, you know that you are dealing with the same mentality, why to bother.

Have you notice that for the progressed Afghani and Pakistani culture ‘blood’, ‘violence’ and knife ‘cutting’ is the only theme they master, even in Art, go figure!

It’s also worth noting that some people get so sensitive when they are called ‘3ara3eer’ and yet they feel it’s ok to call everybody else names, and they become so quite when a ‘3r3our’ of them use a sectarian term on others…sure we all believe your high balanced ‘standards’.

Thumb up 8 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 1:07 pm


887. jad said:

Shooting RPG like thing from a residential roof top by an ‘angel’ in Homs
قصف عشوائي ومن منازل المواطنين في حمص

Thumb up 7 Thumb down 2

March 23rd, 2012, 1:12 pm


888. Mawal95 said:

The talk above about Saidnaya reminds me of the following pro-Bashar singing gem at a concert in Saidnaya in year 2010: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TapKe-h6mWo . The singer is the great Najwa Karam. For Najwa fans, here’s another song from the same concert in Saidnaya but not with political lyrics: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8lpW01NPEH4

You can call it Saydnaya or Saidnaya. But “Sednaya” is uncouth and unacceptable.

When Joshua Landis spoke of “Sednaya” at the top of this thread, he meant to say Zabadani, of course. It was a Freudian slip of Joshua to say “Sednaya” when he meant to say Zabadani, with the Freudianism arising from Joshua’s sectarianism — so it appears to me.

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 5

March 23rd, 2012, 1:27 pm


889. Afram said:

operation I,m syriano

‘Nuff with Pushing a Baloney bloody culture!
I,m,I,m&I,m………we are syrian citizens NOT hostages or circus creatures.

Im sick&tired of the DOG and PONY show,s

we all know the middle east is a mad house,like living in the belly of the beast,some of us like to parade in their Psycho Costume because culturly we are conditioned to walk in a Lunatic White Straight Jackets,that is slavery,full stop.

every one has the right to believe in their fairy tales,but for the sake of my lord the Flying Spaghetti Monster do not spoon feeded forcefully on others.

full disclosure(FD)I,m a certified Atheist-Humanist
chill out folks!

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 1:28 pm


890. Alan said:

Syria hit with increased sanctions as violence surges
European foreign ministers have extended sanctions on 12 additional people in Syria including imposing a travel ban and asset freeze on President Bashar al-Assad’s mother, sister, sister-in-law, and wife, Asma al-Assad. The decision came after this weeks’ leak of Assad emails, many of which show Asma shopping for expensive jewels, furniture, and other luxurious goods. The travel ban will prevent Asma from traveling in Europe except for Britain, where she retains citizenship. Meanwhile, the main opposition group, the Syrian National Council, criticized the United Nation’s statement adopted Wednesday supporting the implementation of the peace plan proposed by U.N. and Arab League envoy, Kofi Annan. Samir Nashar, a member of the council’s executive committee, said that “such statements, issued amid continued killings, offer the regime the opportunity to push ahead with its repression in order to crush the revolt by the Syrian people.” Elsewhere 10 people, half of whom were women and children, were killed in an attack by the regime on a bus fleeing the violence. Severe fighting also raged in Damascus, Latakia, Homs, and Hama where death counts range between 40 and 63. Free Syrian Army forces also killed two Syria soldiers and captured 18 others near the border with Turkey.

Thumb up 2 Thumb down 2

March 23rd, 2012, 1:28 pm



Gift purchased, credit card holder is not under sanctions for aiding murders.. Charge Approved

Many many thanks TARA, I appreciate the help. I think I will write your description on the card. BTW, Aboud is OK, and we are still on for our stroll

You Are A Squirrel
Michel. I wish I can have your relaxed attitude. Many hamsters insist that I am a Squirrel an not a Hamster the moment I write that I like tree tops more than rat-holes. It still upsets me. On SC, they insist on calling me a rat (which is 5 times my size)

Cost of Hypnosis Aid
Son of Damascus, given the extent of hypnosis, do you think that a $3,398,167,211,546,112,618 (To read the number Hint: it is one third of the cost of harpoon missiles provided to Israel according to @882) was enough to give Bernie for hypnosis tools against dumb easily hypnnotizable Airabs.

HALABI, You mean as an atheist, I am not 3ar3oori. How could you, you are not Syrian, nor a Halabi.

I wonder if there is an Urdu or Pashto word to describe a person who uses racist argument to disguise a sectarian one.

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 11

March 23rd, 2012, 1:49 pm


892. norman said:

Thanks to the people who welcomed me,

Tara, Majed,

This is for you so according to Islam he was not crussified ,


Was i right?.I think so .

Thumb up 10 Thumb down 2

March 23rd, 2012, 2:08 pm


893. Halabi said:

Whatever. I believe my limited posts here show that I haven’t insulted any sect and I recently called out Tlass on his disgusting language. It’s not my job to denounce every transgression by anonymous commentators. My issue has always been freedom and democracy and it always will be. The pro-Assad camp would like nothing more than to kill, imprison or expel everyone who thinks like me so that only the 3ara3eer are left.

That’s not going to happen. I’ve taken a pledge to support this revolution that will give all Syrians freedom of speech and rule of law that will help us build a better country. When Bashar runs away into exile, the liberal wing of the opposition will be the ones with the credibility to wage political battle with extremists and defend our delusional brothers and sisters who decided to sacrifice their neighbors so that Bashar and his descendants can rule for another century.

All dictators have an expiration date. Maybe Bashar will rule us until his death, but it won’t be forever. If he does, he will never regain legitimacy. The regime and its supporters will have to continue to kill and oppress its opponents because we will never be silent. Our voices have always been the biggest threat to this regime – the guns and bombs are merely a nuisance. That’s why the jails are packed with political prisoners while criminals and regime-allied terrorists roam free.

Thumb up 6 Thumb down 9

March 23rd, 2012, 2:09 pm


894. Mina said:

Thanks for the videos you have posted: look, as usual, half the people here are KIDS, I mean, very young teenagers!!!

Thumb up 10 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 2:10 pm


895. Mina said:

854 Majed
No, I say a “Sunni” hails the way of the prophet and tries to imitate him because he considers that he was perfect, and for this reason he tries to apply the (contradictory) hadiths.
When people call themselves Sunnis and call for massacres, they are obviously outside what they claim to advocate. Therefore, I said “brainwashed”. Look at the Saudis: according to them, in Hanbali law, Shafii law, you will only see that “the people have to obey the ruler, because this one has been chosen by God, since God creates everything that happens at every minute”.
Don’t worry, I am pretty sure that brainwashed Shiis, brainwashed Christians, and brainwashed Jews exist too. They haven’t been big in the demos in Syria yet.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 2:23 pm


896. Mina said:

Very strange line in the article about the Toulouse guy: “The murderer then barricaded himself in his apartment until he suddenly decided to jump out of a window. As he was falling he got sprayed with bullets by the hundreds of police who were besieging the building.”

Actually, he was waiting for them with three guns and got a bullet in the head. Interesting distorsion… What was the author’s purpose I wonder?

Thumb up 7 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 2:28 pm


897. jad said:


When the adults become nothing but bunch of hypocrites cowards hiding behind their kids and arming them to go kill others you know how bright the future is.

To be honest, I’m not sure how that guy was killed, I wasn’t following the news that closely, maybe this is another version of what happened? I don’t have any explanation for that. Sorry!

It’s also interesting that this bloody conflict is not yet over and people are calling for another battle after the radicals win…we all know how the liberal Libyans are doing lately.

BTW, a new ‘Aljazeera-SC’ news round post is on.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 2:31 pm


898. omen said:

jad @ 1:12 pm

now show helicopters in the sky strafing people (including the unarmed) on the ground.

Thumb up 5 Thumb down 4

March 23rd, 2012, 6:06 pm


899. Jad said:

[greenlight Jad, I edited the N-word to avoid search-engine attention. The N-word is deeply offensive, not a mere historical anomaly. Please be careful with epithets. Nusayri is a word found in historical and ethnological works and in recent discussion. Technically, Nusayri is merely old-fashioned, not in and of itself degrading, as with N– . It is ninety years out of date.

What is at issue for me are comments like these:

-Not only Sunni say Nusayris are not Musslems, everyone who studied Nusayri religion came to the conclusion that they are not Musslems
-Nusayri are persians Alawis are Arab
-Latakia and the syrian coast is for Syria and for real syrians not the Nusayri

Mjabali has stood up for Majedkhaldoun, abhorring his statements, but defending his right as a Syrian to make them. In this case, as with Tara and Bronco’s dispute, it seems Syrians should trump the moderator — unless Joshua objects. ]

Many African Americans call themselves N– when they talk to each others.

Is that enough reason for a White American to call them N–?

Or is it ok for Americans/Europeans to call Arabs from the gulf Sand N—s or Syrians Towel Head?
It’s all the same: Racism and Sectarianism

But when Wahabis and Salafis call themselves that then they choose it, nobody else gave them that name.

Continue to prove our sectarianism doesn’t make us more sectarian of what we are, no point.

Thumb up 9 Thumb down 6

March 23rd, 2012, 9:58 pm


900. habib said:

877. Halabi

There are black Republicans and Nazi Jews. Go figure. Also, ever heard of “tokenism”? Hell, the MB members of the SNC even admitted they only have token seculars to please the West.

Thumb up 3 Thumb down 3

March 24th, 2012, 6:06 am


Pages: « 18 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 [18] Show All

Post a comment